Lugbe AMAC Abuja Nigeria

Unsustainable Paper Voting in Nigeria – A Case for Electronic Voting.

Despite the relevance of the elections in Nigerian’s democratic transition, all elections in Nigeria till date have been marred by series of crisis and irregularities. The use of paper voting in these elections can largely be blamed for these occurrences. Easy accessibility, destructibility and alteration of ballot boxes, ballot papers and result sheets appear to have encouraged hooliganism around these materials, as well as endangering the lives of officials and voters. Also, the tendency for error and fraud is high because of the human factor in the administration of polling activities.

In spite of laudable electoral reforms over the years, election challenges and associated ills are still exacerbating, and in some instance taking new dangerous dimensions. The problem appear to be the more of the method than the process. It is clearly evident that paper balloting seem ill-suited for Nigerian political environment. Continued reforms of the process will most likely contribute little or nothing to offering a credible election, and will endlessly push more willing voters away from the polls, and extinguish the faint enthusiasm of the few strong-willed voting population.

Electronic voting is best suited to deal with the peculiarities of the Nigerian society – from simplifying logistics challenges to solving the issue of inclusivity, voter apathy, and transparency in counting and collation of results.

Argument that Nigeria isn’t ripe for adoption of e-voting system, though real, is far-fetched, and mostly premised on lack of trust of the electoral umpire. I will proceed to make a case for the adoption of e-voting system and why it is the best system for the peculiarity of Nigerian state, while addressing the concerns of oppositions to the e-voting system.

Issues with existing paper voting system

The popularity of paper voting system amongst many nations of the world notwithstanding, the system has continued to dent the credibility of Nigerian democracy by alienating the electorate from governance process.  Since the return of democracy in 1999, elections have been done using the paper voting system with resultant colossal human, material, time and financial cost to the nations at every turn. This continue to throw up disturbing credibility issues both for the elections and the electoral management body.

Nigerian paper balloting has always been stained with blood. Election-related violence has claimed so many lives, with 2011 presidential poll being the highest since the return of democracy. 800 lives were lost following the ensuing three-day violent rioting/sectarian killings in some northern states according to Human Right Watch . 65,000 persons were also displaced. This crisis was attributed to ill-guided reactions from angry voters for perceived manipulation of votes akin to paper balloting. Most recently, Nigeria Civil Society Situation Room reported that about 58 persons lost their lives as a result of 2019 election-related violence .

There have not been shortage of other paper balloting ills. Issues like logistics challenges (typically late or non-arrival of election materials), intimidation of voters, snatching of ballot boxes, ballot stuffing, diversion of electoral materials, multiple voting, underage voting, impersonation, complicity of security agencies, delay in declaration of results, incorrect thumb printing, vote buying, slow process with the resultant long queues, falsification of results, inaccuracy in counting and collation of the electorate votes, are always manifesting.

Paper balloting system has come at a huge and increasing cost. According to the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), it spent N112.9 billion for the conduct of elections in 2011(for 73.5 million voters), N108.8 billion in 2015(for 68.8 million voters) and a mammoth N242 billion (for 84 million voters) for the 2019 elections . INEC spends so much money in recruiting, training and deploying huge number of personnel, including security agents, required to administer the paper ballot system of election. Of the N242 billion proposed for 2019 elections, N85 billion was for logistics covering storing/housing and movement of election materials and one (1) million INEC’s electoral officers.

In 2019 elections, logistics challenges resulted in last minute (election eve) postponement of election for a week, with INEC attributing it to problems in the distribution of ballot papers and results sheets, as well as sabotage, after three fires at its offices in two weeks. Lagos Chamber of Commerce and Industry estimated the cost of the postponement on the economy at $1.5 billion . The postponement also contributed to the low voters’ turn out. Despite having over 15 million voters more than 2015, 2,382,281 less Nigerians were accredited to vote in 2019, making it the lowest election turnout in Nigeria’s 20-year history as a democracy. Recall that the dates for ballot were announced more than a year before the elections. 

 The increasing number of invalid votes in the Nigerian election has become a major concern. This has resulted in a number of inconclusive gubernatorial ballot in the past. Majority of invalid votes arose from smear of the ink beyond one political party box on the ballot paper, resulting from wrong thumb-printing or improper folding of the ballot paper. Aside the two major political parties, invalid votes came third in the 2019 election result at 1,289,607 votes, representing close to half the difference between the votes scored by the winner and the runner-up. This has been recurring over the years. During the April 2011 presidential election, 1,259,506 votes were rejected as invalid out of the 39,469,484 votes cast; and in 2015 presidential election, 844,519 votes were rejected as invalid out of the 29,432,083 votes cast . This shows that a great number of voter, though participated in the elections, were disenfranchised by the inherent flaw in the voting system.

Repeated logistics challenges have also caused inconclusive process, and restiveness amongst voters, often degenerating into violence. Rogue electoral officials are easily recruited for fraud because of the ease at which they can manipulate the materials, process or results of the ballot system. Intended and unintended errors are easier to manifest in this system because of human factor.

Paper balloting have also not fully catered for people with disability. They can be wrongfully guided to vote for the wrong candidate.

Manual transmission and collation of results have thrown up erroneous and contentious results, giving rise to many post-election litigations at a huge cost to the country. A recent case of a senatorial election in Imo State where the returning officers was reported to have declared a doctored result under duress.

With continuous occurrence of these electoral problems, and the enormous liability that comes with it, there is need to look beyond the paper balloting for solution.

E-voting – A panacea to paper voting challenges.

Electronic device can be used for the purpose of casting votes, instead of paper. Often, e-voting is confused for i-voting (internet voting), though internet voting is a type of e-voting. Nigeria has used electronic devices in voter registration (EVR – Electronic Voter Register), and voter verification (Card reader). Though these devices were deployed to ease the process and eliminate fraud, their contributions were wiped off when they were accompanied by paper-voting. We can all attest to the resounding contributions of technology on other areas of life like corruption fight, banking, business management, education, communication and travels which is a pointer to its ability to ease up processes and enthrone transparency. 

New South Wales Electoral Commission (NSWEC), broadly categories e-voting system into two: Direct Recording and Enumeration (DRE) systems, and Remote Electronic Voting (REV) Systems . With DRE systems, e-voting devices are installed at polling units prior to the commencement of voting, while with REV systems, voters can access the voting system at any location through a smart phone or a web browser of an Internet enabled computer. Though REV system has advantage in that it can use the existing infrastructures like phones and computer systems remotely, DRE is better suited for Nigerian political system because of high incidences of illiteracy, technological backwardness and poor access to internet facilities.

Electronic Voting System (EVS), can permit conducting all voting (Presidential, governorship, National and State assemblies) on the same day. Accreditation, voting, counting and result collation process will be faster, requiring lesser number of personnel, real-time, error free, and at reduced cost. This will reduce the ills like vote buying, logistics issues and violence, totally eliminate void votes, multiple voting, impersonation and falsification of results. Overall, transparency and integrity of the ballot will be guaranteed.

Multi-cultural, multi-religious and multi-ethnic reality of Nigerian state naturally breeds trust and confidence issues which faith in technology might help to ameliorate. The overwhelming acceptance of electronic banking system shows that Nigeria society has a history of trust on the use of technology.

Across the globe, many nations are gradually adopting EVS either partly or wholly in the conduct of their elections. Countries like USA, Belgium, Brazil, Bolivia, Mexico, and Philippines have successfully used EVS in the conduct of elections. The last European parliamentary held earlier this year was successfully done with e-voting. In 2014, Namibia became the first African nation to use EVS. The Electoral Institute for Sustainable Democracy in Africa (EISA) adjudged the Namibia election to be largely successful, and the experience became a reference point for the rest of Africa.

In Nigeria, EVS was deployed by Kaduna State government in the conduct of the 2018 Local Government chairmanship elections. Kaduna State Independent Election Commission (SIECOM) modelled the Electronic Voting Machine (EVM) after that of Brazil. The EVMs used were lightweight (about 10kg), therefore were easy to transport. They are boxlike devices, and shaped like medium-sized printers. They feature 1.8GHz quad-core processors, 2GB RAM, 8GB ROM, 12.2-inch LED backlit touch display, USB 2.0, fingerprint scanner, SIM and PSAM slots, 13,000 mAH (battery life of 10-16 hours) and run on Android 5.1. They were programmed to automatically cut out blank votes and ensures quick counting of results. Each EVM has wide touch screen on which political party logos are displayed. Voter on making his/her choice, presses the green button to affirm their choice or the red button to cancel. Afterwards, an in-built thermal printer prints a slip to indicate that they have voted. The printed ballot slip contains SIECOM logo, logo and name of party chosen, date and time of vote cast and the serial number of the EVM. These receipts provide paper trail for auditability of the votes casted. The EVM prints the result at the conclusion of polls, automatically transmit same result electronically to the server room at KAD-SEICOM while storing same in its internal storage, thereby providing three different verification sources.

Because of low internet penetration in some of the areas these polling units were located, KAD-SIECOM chose virtual SIM cards to connect to any available network. EVM’s transmitted live-results were visible via a large screen.

Kaduna local elections were far less contentious, and highly applauded even by opposition, and that served as a confirmation of EVS’s suitability to Nigerian Society. Local Government elections in Nigerian are usually marred by irregularity, with the party in power always winning all the seats. In the case of Kaduna, the main opposition won three Chairmanships and some council seats. KAD-SIECOM reportedly saved N1.7 billion that would have been used in printing ballot papers.

Opposition to E-voting, a question of time, distrust or workability?

“Nigeria is not ripe” appear the most recurring responses when e-voting is discussed. But, truly, are we not ripe? I believe we are. A look at so many nations that have rejected EVS at one point or the other indicated that distrust, especially from the opposition party, was the basis for the rejection. The workability and suitability were often not tested nor questioned. A 2016 research by Uzedhe and Okhaifoh on e-voting solutions to Nigerian electoral system found that in Germany, e-voting was abandoned because of lawsuit questioning the constitutionality of EVS; in Ireland and Netherland, it was the opposition complaint on accuracy and secrecy of EVS, as well as the possibility of result verification; while in the United kingdom, it was the security complaints from the opposition parties.

Issues of illiteracy, privacy and vulnerability to hack have been touted too. Are these genuine concerns? Yes, they are, but they are not enough as there are workable measures to arrest these concerns.

Illiteracy for technology cannot be any worse than that of paper. EVS appear much easier because of very simple design, interactive user interface, and few steps required in voting. Aggressive sensitization and voter education are required to enlighten voters and get them accustomed to EVM use. For the purpose of auditability or verifiability, paper trail should be adopted, just like the case in Kaduna Local elections. Vulnerability to hack can be eliminated by using DRE standalones (keeping electoral process away from the internet), allowing results to be transmitted via a GSM network facility. EVMs are often fitted with SIM cards. Just like in case of Kaduna, virtual SIM cards can be used to connect to available network in low internet penetration areas. Lack of use of internet also reduced incidences of privacy leak. EVMs has security features that allow memory wipe after series of failed attempted logins.

Looking ahead

If Nigerians can trust the Automated Teller Machines (ATMs) for cash transfers, withdrawals and transactions without questioning the provider of the technology and operator of the machine, then it tells that our major issue is not the suitability or workability of EVS but the credibility of the electoral umpire. Our concerns therefore should be properly directed by ensuring that the best team is assembled to head the Nigeria’s election management body.

We can improve on the EVMs deployed by KAD-SIECOM to include verification measures. Aside finger print authentication, other verification methods like Iris recognition, and Artificial Intelligence (AI) face recognition can be added to provide alternatives in any case any fails, and for physically challenged voters. Headphone can be incorporated to aid the blind instead of allowing their guide make the decision on their behalf.

For greater awareness, mock elections can be organized so that voters can get acquainted with the technology, with the exercise invariably raising enthusiasm and hope in the process. Piloting can be done in state elections before escalation to the national elections, allowing ample time for correction of mistakes at a smaller scale. 

The electoral umpire need to commence the design for a suitable technological framework for EVS while carrying the relevant stakeholders along. The National Assembly need to commence amendment to electoral laws allowing the use of EVS. The legal and technical components need to be readied as soon as possible.

Getting the e-voting right opens window to finding uncontestable ways to remotely capture all Nigerians in future irrespective of their locations. First things first; let’s change the method.

Comments (69)

This is an interesting perspective. I have always argued that we as a country, are not yet ready for technology in our elections, but I guess my thoughts have been on the use of I-voting which is clearly not what you are advocating for. Supervised standalone EVS a you advocated might be the best way to go. How can we know if we don’t try it. Paper balloting have obviously failed us badly. You don’t keep throwing fish to the cat and expect it not to eat it. Nice one. Kudos

A very thoughtful analytical piece. I really agree with your recommendations & way forward for the Nigerian state and its electoral system. If only our desperate lawmakers & electoral body would approve for a system devoured of manipulation and fraud.
Kudos Lotanna.

The major problem is the present corrupt government adopting it. This is exactly the same system that is used by almost every developed country today.

Ruth Doosuur Ikyumeh

Lotanna I must say the paper is a credible, and most interestingly the simple register used to pass on this message which I believe needs no further explanation. Also, your write is explicit and has an all round coverage. If the e-voting policy can be adopted, a huge positive effect will be felt in all ramifications. Electing of leaders will be more of a personal decision.
Kudos Sir, more grace.

This’s great.. nice one

A very interesting write up. If e-voting worked for Kaduna SAICOM, surely INEC can adopt same for general elections. The greatest challenge to this is corrupt politicians, tribal and religious bigots.

What a piece. We really need to do things using different methods. Let’s try first. Well-done well analyzed with points to prove. Well done once again

What a piece. We really need to do things using different methods. Let’s try first. Well-done well analyzed with points to prove. Well done once again

This piece is quite apt and the best solution so far to the huge resources spent on paper voting . There is no value for money when one compares the huge amount spent in organizing election through paper voting since the first democratic election. If we keep saying Nigeria is not ready, my question is when will it be ready. Yes a lot of people were skeptical of using the ATM but that is not so now because of enlightenment. Many people enjoy it’s services now and same can be applied to the e-voting suggested by this Lotanna.

Wow great work and quite informative

Thoughtful insight, I couldn’t agree more. The challenge is the power brokers who would rather sit on the status quo than to allow a system that will surely topple them. But with insistence from pressure groups, CSOs and the masses, I believe we can push it through.

Thoughtful insight, I couldn’t agree more. The challenge is the power brokers who would rather sit on the status quo than to allow a system that will surely topple them. But with insistence from pressure groups, CSOs and the masses, I believe we can push it through

Awesome piece! Something to reflect on.
Often times, ideas and innovations are rejected out of fear; fear of losing a job, fear of gaining new experience, or even, the fear of blazing the trail. Evidently, fear do not leave room for growth. Nigeria embracing the e-voting system is one way of kicking fear in the “butt” and I reckon Nigerians are ready. What better time is there to start!

Lota, this is wonderful.
If a state in Nigeria (Kaduna State) can use EVM for their election, I think INEC officials all over Nigeria have to ask themselves question. They have to adopt this to make elections in Nigeria henceforth free and fair.

NTYgop Looking forward to reading more. Great blog.Much thanks again. Really Great.

Hi, very nice website, cheers!
——————————————————
Need cheap and reliable hosting? Our shared plans start at $10 for an year and VPS plans for $6/Mo.
——————————————————
Check here: https://www.good-webhosting.com/

S design houses In third place is michael kors canada, rising two spots in the ranks from Tuesday,

I think the admin of this site is genuinely working hard

put this information together. I once again find myself spending a lot of time both reading and commenting.

I value the blog.Much thanks again. Great. ventolin

Wow, marvelous blog layout! How long have you ever been running a blog for? you made running a blog glance easy. The whole look of your site is fantastic, as well as the content material!

I truly appreciate this blog.Really thank you! Want more.

you employ a fantastic weblog here! want to earn some invite posts on my website?

This is my first time go to see at here and i am truly impressed to read all at one place.

It is best to take part in a contest for among the best blogs on the web. I will advocate this website!

I truly appreciate this post.Much thanks again. Really Great.

Tremendous things here. I am very happy to see your article. Thanks a lot and I am taking a look ahead to contact you. Will you kindly drop me a mail?

Looking forward to reading more. Great article post.Really looking forward to read more. Really Great.

You have done an impressive job and our entire community

Outstanding post however , I was wanting to know if you could write a litte more on this subject? I ad be very thankful if you could elaborate a little bit more. Thank you!

Im grateful for the article post.Thanks Again. Really Great.

your posts more, pop! Your content is excellent but with pics and videos, this site could definitely be one of the best

we came across a cool internet site which you may possibly love. Take a look if you want

Your style is very unique in comparison to other people I ave read stuff from. I appreciate you for posting when you have the opportunity, Guess I all just bookmark this web site.

Pretty component to content. I just stumbled upon your weblog and in accession capital to assert that I acquire in fact enjoyed account your blog posts. Anyway I will be subscribing on your feeds or even I success you get entry to constantly quickly.

Well I sincerely liked reading it. This article provided by you is very constructive for correct planning.

The issue is something which too few people are speaking intelligently about.

I’а†ve read various fantastic stuff here. Undoubtedly worth bookmarking for revisiting. I surprise how a whole lot try you set to generate this form of great informative internet site.

Your style is very unique compared to other people I ave read stuff from. Thanks for posting when you have the opportunity, Guess I will just bookmark this page.

Thankyou for this marvelous post, I am glad I detected this website on yahoo.

you might have an important weblog here! would you wish to make some invite posts on my blog?

It as best to take part in a contest for one of the best blogs on the web. I all recommend this site!

Im grateful for the article post.Thanks Again. Much obliged.

Wonderful article! We are linking to this particularly great post on our website. Keep up the good writing.

Right now it seems like WordPress is the best blogging platform available right now. (from what I ave read) Is that what you are using on your blog?

I value the blog post.Much thanks again. Great.

Nice post. I be taught something more difficult on different blogs everyday. It will at all times be stimulating to learn content from other writers and follow a bit one thing from their store. I’d prefer to make use of some with the content material on my weblog whether you don’t mind. Natually I’ll give you a hyperlink on your internet blog. Thanks for sharing.

This website was how do you say it? Relevant!! Finally I have found something which helped me. Thanks a lot!

Thank you one million and please carry on the rewarding

Muchos Gracias for your post.Thanks Again. Really Cool.

I see something truly special in this website.

Howdy exceptional blog! Does running a blog similar to this require a
lot of work? I have absolutely no understanding of programming however
I was hoping to start my own blog in the near future.
Anyways, if you have any recommendations or techniques for new blog owners please share.
I understand this is off topic nevertheless I just wanted
to ask. Appreciate it!

Thanks again for the article post.Really thank you! Awesome.

Thanks so much for the blog article.Really looking forward to read more. Really Cool.

You have brought up a very wonderful details , thanks for the post.

I am regular visitor, how are you everybody? This post posted at this site is really pleasant.

Thanks for fantastic info I was searching for this info for my mission.

Major thanks for the blog. Really Great.

Im thankful for the blog post.Thanks Again. Great.

Thanks in favor of sharing such a fastidious thinking,

It as really a nice and helpful piece of info. I am glad that you shared this helpful information with us. Please keep us up to date like this. Thank you for sharing.

This unique blog is no doubt entertaining and besides diverting. I have found many useful advices out of this amazing blog. I ad love to go back over and over again. Cheers!

This page really has all the information I wanted about this subject and didn’t know who to ask.

Really appreciate you sharing this blog article.Really thank you! Cool.

Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic article post.Really thank you! Fantastic.

Thanks so much for the post. Will read on

It as simple, yet effective. A lot of times it as very difficult to get that perfect balance between superb usability and visual appeal.

It’s perfect time to make some plans for the longer term and
it’s time to be happy. I have read this put up and if I
may I wish to counsel you few attention-grabbing issues or suggestions.
Perhaps you could write next articles regarding this article.

I want to learn more things approximately it!

The Birch of the Shadow I feel there may become a several duplicates, but an exceedingly helpful list! I have tweeted this. Quite a few thanks for sharing!

Leave a comment